Chromatik
Any program that has me running for my flute (because it is quickly assembled) and playing for more than a half hour
definitely has two thumbs up from me. While I played my flute, I literally had a sing-along with my (almost) three-year-old daughter! (She left the movie she was watching to come sing!) It was a ton of fun, and it had a decent selection of songs that she knew to make it more fun.
I can see how Chromatik would be highly motivating for students of nearly any age. To play along on an instrument, students would have to be experienced (high school?) players. Some songs had huge ranges, so players either have to be able to play extreme ranges (Flute low Bb in "Gaston", for example) or be able to transpose the octave easily. The key signatures are original and often difficult when transposed for different instrument (clarinet or sax). I also appreciated that there is an 'easy' keyboard version (even if it is still difficult)!
Chromatik, a free online program, uses YouTube videos as the audio accompaniment for the songs. The advantage: you hear the original song without midi accompaniment, which at times sounds tacky. The disadvantages: some songs have explicit language that is censored in the sheet music but not in the audio, and some of the videos are 'no longer accessible'.
Overall, Chromatik has definite applications for experienced players for sight-reading skills, motivation to play, and just fun. Students would likely spend quite a bit of time playing their favorite songs, and exploring music from different genres.
But what about the elementary music classroom?
As with many of the programs in this class, much of Chromatik's content would be too difficult for elementary students. However, I could imagine using this as a reward or extra-curricular activity. If you select the 'Vocal' choice (or really, any of them as they all seem to have the lyrics in the music), students could follow along with the sheet music and sing along. I would use this on my SMART Board, with the goal of students improving fluency (following along in the music isn't always easy). Many music videos with lyrics go too fast, and don't allow the reader to look ahead.
SmartMusic
SmartMusic is a subscription program in which teachers can assign playing assignments, assess students' playing, and monitor student growth. Students use an Internet connection to play along with lesson book songs, technical exercises, or even ensemble repertoire.
I have heard of this program in the past, but technology and budgetary limitations (and our district's instrumental program being cut) have prevented me from exploring its use. Now that I have reinstated an instrumental program at our magnet school, and the use of technology is encouraged, I hope that I can roll out use of SmartMusic over the next year or two.
The program seems very motivating - students not only have accompaniments that they can change to a playable tempo, but the program gives the student instant feedback on pitch and rhythm issues in their playing. The program can give them an instant score - and who doesn't want to keep playing their 'game' to get a perfect score?
Testimonials on the website give high praise to SmartMusic. Students and full ensembles seem to advance more quickly in their playing abilities, performing more difficult music.
With all these things in mind, I think adding SmartMusic to my new band program could be 'instrumental' to its success. I am having a difficult time motivating my students to practice, and adding this program could increase playing times and student achievement.
But you have mentioned that your families may have financial and Internet connectivity issues?!
In a school like mine, I couldn't make the use of SmartMusic a mandatory exercise. I would offer the families the opportunity to subscribe to it at home (possibly with magnet funds paying for part of their subscription), but I would also have several 'practice room subscriptions' available at school for student use. I can imagine the students using it on indoor recess days, signing up to use it before school, or during the after-school program.
In Conclusion... I
definitely want to find a way to use both of these programs with my students!